Know your pasta

Carbonara vs. Alfredo, From the Ingredients to the First Bite

Both look creamy. In their original Roman versions, neither one contains any cream.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

Bucatini carbonara on a BASTA plate

Carbonara and Alfredo are the two best-known “white” pasta sauces, and they are easy to confuse. Both are rich, both cling to the pasta and both come from Rome. But the comparison of carbonara vs Alfredo shows two very different sauces.

What is in each sauce?

CarbonaraAlfredo
BaseEggsButter
CheesePecorino RomanoParmigiano Reggiano
MeatCured porkNone
SeasoningLots of black pepperVery little
CreamNot in the classic versionNot in the original, common in American versions

Carbonara

Classic carbonara has four main ingredients besides the pasta: eggs, pecorino cheese, cured pork and black pepper. The pork is traditionally guanciale, which comes from the cheek.

The technique is what makes it special. The hot pasta is tossed with the egg and cheese mixture off the heat. The warmth of the pasta thickens the eggs into a glossy sauce without scrambling them. There is no cream. The silkiness comes entirely from the eggs, the cheese and a little pasta water.

How it tastes: savory, salty and peppery, with rich bites of pork.

Alfredo

The original Alfredo comes from a Roman restaurant in the early 1900s and has just two ingredients: butter and Parmigiano, tossed with fresh fettuccine until they melt into a sauce.

The version most Americans know is different. It adds heavy cream, and often garlic, to make a thicker, more stable sauce. It is frequently served with chicken.

How it tastes: mild, buttery and creamy.

The first bite

Carbonara hits with salt, pepper and pork right away. It is bold. Alfredo is gentler and rounder, with a soft dairy flavor. If you like strong, savory food, you will lean toward carbonara. If you like mild and creamy, Alfredo is your sauce.

Which pasta goes with each?

Carbonara is usually served with spaghetti, rigatoni or bucatini. Alfredo belongs with fettuccine. In both cases the shape gives the sauce plenty of surface to cling to.

What we serve at BASTA

Our menu has Bucatini Carbonara, made with our fresh bucatini.

We do not serve Alfredo. In its place is our Pappardelle Cacio e Pepe, which the menu describes as “not alfredo, just better.” It is a peppery cream sauce made with Parmigiano and pecorino, finished with crispy breadcrumbs. If Alfredo is your usual order, start there.

A note for anyone avoiding eggs or pork

Carbonara contains both. If you have allergies or dietary restrictions, ask our team about ingredients before you order.

Read more about the cheese sauce in what is cacio e pepe, or see how the pasta differs in bucatini vs spaghetti.

“I lived in Italy for 2 years and this food is as authentic as it gets.”

Abigail A.Google review, Murray

Keep reading