Know your pasta

Bucatini vs. Spaghetti, and What That Tiny Hole Changes

They look almost the same in the bowl. One of them is secretly a tube.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

Two nests of fresh long pasta on a white plate

From across the table, bucatini and spaghetti are hard to tell apart. Both are long, round strands. Pick one up, though, and you will notice the difference. In the matchup of bucatini vs spaghetti, everything comes down to a hole about the width of a pin.

What is bucatini?

Bucatini is a thick, spaghetti-like pasta with a narrow hollow running through the center, like a very long straw. The name comes from “buco,” the Italian word for hole. It is closely tied to Rome and the surrounding region.

What is spaghetti?

Spaghetti is a solid, round strand. The name means “little strings.” It is thinner than bucatini and found all over Italy and the rest of the world.

Side by side

BucatiniSpaghetti
ShapeThick strand with a hollow centerSolid, thinner strand
TextureChewy and springyTender and smooth
Cooking timeLongerShorter
Best withRich, clingy saucesLight and smooth sauces

What the hole changes

Texture. Bucatini is thicker, so it has more chew. The bite is bouncy in a way spaghetti is not.

Cooking. Water flows through the center, so the pasta cooks from the inside as well as the outside. That lets a thick strand cook evenly.

Sauce. A little sauce gets drawn into the tube. With a rich sauce, each bite carries flavor on the outside and a trace on the inside.

Eating. Bucatini is harder to twirl and famous for flicking sauce. Lean in. It is worth it.

Which sauces suit each one?

Bucatini is the classic partner for amatriciana, a Roman sauce of tomato, cured pork and pecorino. It is also excellent with carbonara, because the sturdy strand stands up to a thick egg and cheese sauce.

Spaghetti suits lighter sauces that coat thin strands evenly: garlic and oil, simple tomato sauce and seafood.

Can you swap them?

Yes, with small adjustments. Bucatini takes a few minutes longer to cook. If a recipe calls for bucatini and you use spaghetti, the dish will be a little lighter and less chewy. Going the other way, expect a heartier bite.

Bucatini at BASTA

We make our pasta fresh every day, and bucatini is the shape we chose for our carbonara. Bucatini Carbonara is on the pasta menu in Murray and Draper. The thick, hollow strands hold the sauce in a way thin spaghetti cannot.

The short answer

Choose spaghetti when the sauce is light. Choose bucatini when the sauce is rich and you want something to chew on.

Want to compare more shapes? Read rigatoni vs penne or our guide to pasta shapes and sauces.

“Would recommend this restaurant if anyone is looking for fresh pasta in the salt lake/ Murray / midvale area.”

Ricky A.Google review, Murray

Keep reading