Know your pasta

The Best Pasta for Vodka Sauce, Tested With Basta’s Rigatoni Vodka

Vodka sauce is thick, smooth and clingy. It needs a shape with somewhere for the sauce to go.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

A pile of fresh rigatoni

Vodka sauce is creamy, smooth and thick enough to coat a spoon. That makes it forgiving, since it sticks to almost anything. But some shapes make it shine. If you are looking for the best pasta for vodka sauce, start with tubes.

What vodka sauce needs from a pasta

A smooth, creamy sauce has no chunks to catch on the pasta. So the shape has to do the work. The best partners have:

  • Hollows that fill with sauce
  • Ridges that hold a coating
  • Enough heft to balance the richness

The contenders

Penne. The traditional choice. Penne alla vodka made the sauce famous. The tubes hold sauce and the shape is easy to eat. Smooth penne lets some sauce slide off, so choose the ridged kind.

Rigatoni. Bigger and wider than penne, with deep ridges. More sauce fits inside each piece, and the thicker walls give a satisfying chew against the creamy sauce.

Shells. Medium shells scoop up sauce like little cups. They are a good choice, especially for kids.

Long noodles. Spaghetti and fettuccine work, but the sauce coats the outside only. You lose the pleasure of a tube full of sauce.

How they compare

ShapeHolds sauceTexture against the sauce
RigatoniInside and outChewy, substantial
PenneInside, less outsideFirm, lighter
ShellsScoops itSoft
Long noodlesOutside onlyDepends on thickness

Why we chose rigatoni

We built our Rigatoni Vodka around this pairing. Our rigatoni is made fresh every day, so it has a tender chew that dried pasta does not. The ridges grab the pink sauce, and the tubes fill up as the pasta is tossed.

Then there is the topping. The dish is finished with a spicy whipped ’nduja ricotta. As you eat, it melts into the sauce and collects in the ridges and tubes. A flat or thin pasta would not hold it the same way.

Tips for making it at home

  1. Cook the pasta a minute short. Finish it in the sauce so it absorbs some flavor.
  2. Save some pasta water. A splash keeps the sauce silky.
  3. Toss over heat. Thirty seconds in the pan helps sauce and pasta come together.
  4. Add cheese at the end. Off the heat, so it melts smoothly.

What to add

Vodka sauce is a good base for extras. Chicken, sausage, burrata and fresh basil are all popular. At BASTA you can add Roasted Chicken, Crispy Chicken or Parm Chicken from the sides menu.

The verdict

Penne is the classic. Rigatoni is the upgrade. If your sauce is thick and creamy, the bigger tube wins.

Read more about the two tubes in rigatoni vs penne, or learn about the sauce in what is vodka sauce.

“Seriously good homemade pasta at a price that compares to large chain Italian restaurant prices, would much rather go here!”

Chrissy A.Google review, Murray

Keep reading