Catering and groups

Pasta Bar Toppings Guests Actually Use, Paired With Three Sauces

Skip the twenty small bowls. These are the toppings that get used, sorted by the sauce they belong with.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

A forkful of pappardelle cacio e pepe

A pasta bar can easily turn into a table of untouched bowls. Guests want a few good choices, not a salad bar. The best pasta bar toppings are the ones that make a sauce taste more like itself. Here is what to set out, organized by the three sauces most pasta bars serve.

The four toppings every pasta bar needs

No matter which sauces you serve, start here:

  • Grated hard cheese. Parmigiano or pecorino. This is the one topping nearly every guest uses.
  • Red chili flakes. For the people who want heat.
  • Fresh basil. Torn leaves add color and a fresh smell.
  • Black pepper. A grinder on the table is enough.

Toppings for tomato sauce

Tomato sauce is bright and a little acidic. It likes creamy and fresh additions:

  • A spoonful of ricotta
  • Fresh mozzarella, torn into pieces
  • Extra basil
  • A drizzle of good olive oil

Toppings for cream sauce

Cream sauces are rich, so they need texture and contrast:

  • Toasted breadcrumbs. The crunch makes a big difference. Our Pappardelle Cacio e Pepe is finished with crispy breadcrumbs for exactly this reason.
  • Freshly cracked black pepper
  • Crisp bacon or pancetta
  • Something green, such as peas or chopped parsley

Toppings for pesto

Pesto is already full of flavor. Keep the additions simple:

  • Toasted pine nuts or pistachios
  • Halved cherry tomatoes
  • Fresh mozzarella or burrata
  • A squeeze of lemon

Proteins on the side

Proteins make the meal more filling. Offer one or two:

  • Meatballs in tomato sauce
  • Sliced roasted or crispy chicken
  • Italian sausage

Keep them in their own warm trays so guests who do not eat meat can pass them by.

A cheat sheet

SauceBest toppings
TomatoRicotta, mozzarella, basil, olive oil
CreamBreadcrumbs, black pepper, pancetta, peas
PestoPine nuts, cherry tomatoes, burrata, lemon

How much to set out

  • Grated cheese: about 1 tablespoon per person. For 25 guests, that is roughly 1.5 cups.
  • Other toppings: about 1 cup of each for every 20 to 25 guests.
  • Proteins: two meatballs or a few slices of chicken per person.

Use small bowls and refill them. Small bowls look full and stay fresh.

Setup tips

  1. Put toppings at the end of the line, after the pasta and sauce.
  2. Give every bowl its own spoon.
  3. Label anything with nuts.
  4. Keep cold toppings like ricotta and mozzarella chilled until serving.

Planning the whole table? Start with our guide to building a pasta bar. When you want the pasta taken care of, BASTA catering can supply the trays while you handle the toppings.

“My wife got the cacio sauce and it was divine.”

Nathan W.Google review, Draper

Keep reading