Know your pasta

Margherita vs. Cheese Pizza, From the Tomatoes to the Finished Slice

Same three building blocks, crust, tomato and cheese. Very different pizzas.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

A Margherita pizza beside two arugula pizzas

A Margherita and a classic American cheese pizza are made from the same basic parts: dough, tomato and mozzarella. Yet nobody would mistake one for the other. The difference in Margherita vs cheese pizza comes from how each ingredient is handled.

At a glance

MargheritaCheese pizza
TomatoSimple, lightly seasonedCooked, seasoned sauce
CheeseFresh mozzarella in piecesShredded, aged mozzarella
CoveragePatches of cheese and sauceCheese edge to edge
HerbsFresh basilUsually dried, in the sauce
FinishOlive oilNone, or grated cheese

The tomatoes

On a Margherita, the tomato is kept simple. It is crushed and lightly salted, so it tastes fresh and bright.

On a cheese pizza, the sauce is usually cooked and seasoned with garlic, oregano and sometimes a little sugar. It is thicker and more savory.

The cheese

This is the biggest difference.

A Margherita uses fresh mozzarella, placed in slices or torn pieces. It melts into soft, milky pools with sauce showing between them.

A cheese pizza uses low-moisture mozzarella, shredded and spread across the whole pie. It browns, bubbles and stretches. This is the cheese that gives you the long pull from a hot slice.

The basil

Fresh basil is the third ingredient that defines a Margherita. It adds a sweet, peppery aroma. A cheese pizza usually has no fresh herbs on top.

The story behind the name

The Margherita is said to be named for Queen Margherita of Italy, who visited Naples in 1889. The red tomato, white mozzarella and green basil match the colors of the Italian flag.

The finished slice

A slice of Margherita is lighter. You taste tomato first, then milky cheese, then basil. The crust matters more because there is less on top of it.

A slice of cheese pizza is richer. The cheese leads, with a savory sauce underneath. It is the more filling of the two.

Which should you order?

  • Order a Margherita if you like fresh, bright flavors and want to taste each ingredient.
  • Order a cheese pizza if you want something rich, gooey and familiar.

For kids who want a plain pizza, either works. A Margherita without the basil is very close to a cheese pizza.

Pizza at BASTA

Our Margherita is made with mozzarella, tomato and basil, the traditional three. If you want something heartier, the Pepperoni adds spicy salame, and the kids menu has a Kids Tomato Pizza.

Sharing tip

A Margherita is the best pizza to share with a table that is also ordering pasta. It is light enough to sit alongside richer dishes without overloading the meal.

Go deeper on the classic in Margherita pizza ingredients, or compare the cheeses in burrata vs. mozzarella.

“Great pizza! Closest to Italy pizza I have had in the U.S.”

Thomas L.Google review, Draper

Keep reading