Ordering and eating

Is Pesto Vegan? What to Ask About the Sauce Before You Order

The short answer is usually no. The longer answer helps you order with confidence.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

Gnocchi in a creamy pesto sauce on a BASTA plate

Pesto is green, made from basil and looks like it should be plant-based. So is pesto vegan? Traditional pesto is not, because it contains cheese. Here is what goes into it and what to ask before you order.

What is in traditional pesto?

Classic basil pesto from Genoa has seven ingredients:

  • Fresh basil
  • Pine nuts
  • Garlic
  • Olive oil
  • Salt
  • Parmigiano Reggiano
  • Pecorino

The first five are plant-based. The last two are cheese.

Why pesto is usually not vegan

Both cheeses are made from milk, so traditional pesto is not vegan. Most jarred pesto in grocery stores also contains cheese, or milk in some form.

Is pesto vegetarian?

It depends on how strict you are. Traditional Parmigiano and pecorino are made with animal rennet, an enzyme used to set the milk. Many vegetarians avoid it. Others are comfortable with it. If it matters to you, ask.

What about restaurant pesto?

Restaurant pesto varies. A kitchen might:

  • Add cream or butter to make the sauce richer
  • Use different nuts, such as walnuts, almonds or pistachios
  • Toss the pasta with extra cheese at the end
  • Serve it on egg pasta or gnocchi that contains dairy or egg

The sauce is only one part of the dish. The pasta and the finishing touches matter too.

Questions to ask before you order

  1. Does the pesto contain cheese?
  2. Is there cream or butter in the sauce?
  3. Is the pasta made with egg?
  4. Is cheese added on top, and can it be left off?
  5. What nuts are in it? This one matters for allergies as well.

A good kitchen will answer these without any trouble.

Pesto at BASTA

Pesto appears in a few places on our menu:

  • Gnocchi Pesto is potato gnocchi in a creamy pesto sauce. It contains dairy.
  • Caprese Focaccia has basil pesto with burrata.
  • Mamma’s Kiss Focaccia has Sicilian pesto with chicken and provolone.
  • Cheesy Garlic Pagnotta has pistachio pesto with burrata.

None of these are vegan as served. If you follow a vegan diet, tell our team when you order and ask what can be adjusted. Recipes change, so it is always best to confirm.

Can pesto be made vegan?

Yes, and easily at home. Leave out the cheese and add one of these for savory depth:

  • Nutritional yeast
  • A spoonful of white miso
  • Extra nuts and a little more salt
  • A squeeze of lemon

The result is bright and herby, a little lighter than the original.

Buying vegan pesto

Check the label. Look for the words vegan or dairy free, and read the ingredient list for cheese, milk, whey or casein.

More help with ordering

See our guides to vegetarian Italian dishes and Italian dining with dietary preferences. For the sauce itself, read what is pesto pasta.

“My wife and I drive an hour to get here, and it’s worth every penny in gas!”

Dean T.Google review, Draper

Keep reading