Catering and groups

How to Feed a High School Team After a Game, With Three Sample Pasta Orders

Athletes eat more than any chart predicts. Here is how to order enough, fast, without overspending.

By BASTA PasteriaNovember 12, 20262 min read

A table full of BASTA dishes: fresh pastas, gnocchi, pizza and more

Anyone who has fed a high school team knows the first rule: order more than you think. Teenagers who have just played a full game can eat twice what an adult does. The best team dinner ideas keep things simple, filling and fast to serve. Pasta has been the team dinner standard for decades for exactly those reasons.

What athletes need from a team dinner

  • Plenty of carbohydrates. Pasta and bread are the foundation.
  • Some protein. Meat sauce, meatballs or chicken.
  • Familiar flavors. A team dinner is not the night to experiment.
  • Speed. Buses and parents are waiting.

Sample order 1: the small squad, about 15 players

  • Two large pasta dishes, one with meat sauce and one with tomato sauce
  • Two or three pizzas
  • Garlic bread or focaccia
  • One big salad

Sample order 2: the full roster, about 25 players

  • Three pasta trays: one Bolognese, one tomato, one creamy
  • Meatballs on the side
  • Pizza for variety
  • Bread and salad

Sample order 3: team and families, about 40 people

  • Three or four pasta trays, including one meatless
  • Lasagna, which holds heat well and serves in neat squares
  • Pizza, bread and two salads
  • A simple dessert

For groups of 20 or more, we size the trays for you. Tell us it is a team of athletes, and we will plan for bigger appetites.

How much to order

Our standard pasta portion chart assumes average adults. For athletes after a game, add a quarter to a third more. It is better to send players home with leftovers than to run out.

Before the game or after?

The night before a competition, keep it plain: tomato sauce, pasta, bread and water. Heavy cream sauces can wait.

After the game, anything goes. This is the meal for meat sauce, cheese and seconds.

Making it run smoothly

  1. Assign one parent to order. One contact, one order, one pickup.
  2. Collect money ahead of time. It saves a lot of awkward math later.
  3. Set up a serving line. Players first, then coaches and families.
  4. Bring plates, forks and napkins. Ask us if you need them, since they are not included automatically.

Ordering for your team

For 20 or more, send a catering request at least 24 hours ahead. We deliver or set up pickup from Murray or Draper. For a smaller group, order online from the regular menu, or bring the team in. Call ahead for a large table so the kitchen is ready.

“We had never been there & took our son & 10 of his friends for dinner for his 12th birthday & we were so impressed with how quickly they accommodated our very large group…”

Amy F.Google review, Murray

Keep reading