Ordering and eating

What to Order at an Italian Restaurant: A Beginner-Friendly Pasta Guide

An easy first-timer’s roadmap from rigatoni vodka and pomodoro to pappardelle and gnocchi.

By BASTA PasteriaOctober 25, 20262 min read

A forkful of carbonara twirled over a BASTA plate

Italian menus can be exciting and confusing at the same time. There are pasta shapes you’ve never heard of, sauces with names that sound similar, and dishes that offer very different textures despite sharing the same basic ingredients.

The easiest way to choose what to order at an Italian restaurant is to stop thinking about memorizing vocabulary. Instead, start with three preferences: the type of sauce you like, the texture you want, and how hearty the meal should feel.

Start with the sauce: tomato, cream or meat?

If you want something bright and straightforward, look for a tomato-forward sauce such as pomodoro. The flavor tends to be centered on tomatoes, with herbs and aromatics playing supporting roles.

If you want something creamier, consider a vodka-style sauce, which commonly combines tomato character with a fuller, silkier texture. If you prefer a rich, substantial dish, Bolognese or another ragù may be more satisfying.

Cheese-based options such as cacio e pepe offer yet another path: savory, peppery and focused on a few ingredients rather than a complex tomato sauce.

Next, choose the pasta texture

Rigatoni is a short, hollow pasta tube that catches sauce inside and along its ridges. Pappardelle is made of wide ribbons, ideal for gathering a rich coating around the fork. Gnocchi is typically a soft Italian dumpling, often made with potato, rather than a conventional noodle.

There’s no right answer here. People who like individual, chewy bites might enjoy rigatoni. Those who like wide noodles may prefer pappardelle. For a soft, comforting texture, gnocchi is worth exploring.

Want a safe first order?

“Safe” in this context means approachable in flavor, not allergy-safe. A tomato pasta such as Rigatoni Pomodoro is a familiar choice for someone who doesn’t want a very rich sauce. Rigatoni Vodka is a good next step if you enjoy something creamier. Pappardelle Bolognese is a hearty choice, and Gnocchi Sorrentina offers a softer texture.

Those are examples from the current BASTA Pasteria menu, where exact ingredients, pricing and availability should be confirmed before ordering.

Add a starter or pizza if you’re sharing

For a table of two or more, combining different formats can be more interesting than ordering identical entrées. Consider a pasta and a Margherita Pizza, or add an antipasto to share before the main dishes arrive.

You don’t have to order every course. Italian dining can be as simple as one satisfying plate of pasta or as relaxed as a shared meal with friends.

Don’t overlook your preferences and restrictions

Ask about spice levels, meat ingredients, cheese, nuts and wheat when they matter to you. Dish names provide a clue, not a complete ingredient list. If you have a food allergy or another medical restriction, the kitchen should confirm whether it can safely meet your needs.

Ready to choose?

BASTA Pasteria serves Italian dishes at its Murray and Draper locations. Start with the menu, choose a sauce that sounds good, and let the pasta shape be part of the discovery. Your favorite Italian dish may be one you haven’t tried yet.

“We were welcomed the moment we walked in the door and Nick made sure to break everything down for us and made great recommendations!”

Lauren K.Google review, Draper

Keep reading